Short answer: moissanite passes the standard handheld diamond tester, and fails the more advanced multi-tester.
How a thermal tester works
The common pen-style tester heats a fine tip and measures how quickly the stone pulls that heat away. Diamond conducts heat extremely well. So does moissanite, which is why it reads as diamond. Cubic zirconia and glass conduct heat poorly and fail.
How a multi-tester tells them apart
Moissanite conducts a small amount of electricity. Almost all diamonds do not. A multi-tester checks electrical conductivity as well as heat, and flags moissanite as moissanite.
Other giveaways
- Double refraction. Looking through the top of a moissanite at an angle with a loupe, facet edges can appear doubled. Diamond does not do this.
- Fire. Moissanite throws more rainbow colour than diamond in bright light.
What this means for you
Moissanite is a gemstone in its own right, not a fake diamond. It should always be sold as moissanite, and you should never resell it as diamond. A jeweler or pawn shop with a multi-tester will identify it in seconds.
Every stone in the Hailstone Moissanite line is moissanite, and every listing says so.